Posted
Apr 2007
Seeking Pleasure? Or Avoiding Pain?
It all depends upon how customers view themselves
Based on the research of Jennifer L. Aaker And Angela Y. Lee
Will your customers respond more strongly to advertising that promises fun, happiness and prosperity? Or will an ad stressing the avoidance of illness or hardship be a better sell?
The answer depends on how your customers see themselves, says Kellogg Marketing Professor Angela Lee. Those who define themselves as individuals - for example, stereotypical Americans -probably will respond more to ads that promise greater enjoyment in life.
Those who see themselves primarily as members of a larger group - for example, people in East Asian cultures - tend to pay more attention to ads suggesting a product will help them avoid a negative fate.
“In the United States, we tend to focus on ‘self-enhancement,’” notes Lee, who investigates the impact of cultural differences on consumer behavior. “We want to better ourselves.
“But in China and other East Asian countries, people tend to see themselves as part of a larger group. It is a more self-critical culture, and people focus more on responsibilities, obligations and security.”
For the Chinese and others with this “interdependent self-view,” membership in the group takes precedence over individual achievement. Therefore, they will respond most strongly to threats to their ability to interact with the group.
They are also more risk-averse, Lee notes, and more influenced by ads that focus on avoiding undesirable outcomes. Ads with a “prevention focus” - those that promise to spare the customer from negative consequences such as disease or danger - appeal more strongly, in general, to those with this view.
Lee says marketers can increase their effectiveness by ensuring that ads appeal to their desired audience’s self-view.
“We pay more attention to what is relevant to us,” says Lee, who published her findings with co-researcher Jennifer L. Aaker of Stanford University in a June 2001 article in the Journal of Consumer Research.
A North American audience in Lee’s study, for example, responded more favorably to sample ads for a tennis racket when these ads stressed the glory of winning a tournament. A Chinese audience, meanwhile, was more persuaded by messages stressing the importance of not losing the tournament.
But self-view can be manipulated, Lee adds, through “priming” - the practice of exposing customers to stimuli that lead them to think about themselves or others in a certain way.
In Lee’s study, for example, the Chinese audiences were read a statement encouraging them to think of their individual interests. They were told they were about to play a championship tennis match and had the chance to bring home a large trophy for themselves.
The North American study subjects, meanwhile, were told their team’s hopes rested on their performance in the match, thus priming them to think in a more interdependent way.
Afterward, the typical Chinese response to the tennis-racket ad reflected a desire to seek a positive outcome, while the North American subjects responded more warmly to advertising that played to their desire to avoid a negative result.
“The notion that people with an independent self-view seek out pleasures while those with an interdependent self view avoid pains helps explain why different people adopt different strategies to achieve their goals,” Lee says.
“What makes it even more interesting is the fact that the way we look at ourselves is not fixed. We are very adaptive and can project ourselves in a different light as the situation changes.”
1 Comment
Jan 9 2008
This differentiation in advertising between individual self-enhancement and group focused pain avoidance is very apparent in car ads.
Most GM, Ford and Chrysler car ads seem to promote their product as enhancing an individual’s enjoyment, freedom, style. In contrast most Toyota and Honda ads seem to focus on a car as a smart choice…smart as in “you won’t embarrass yourself, we are the safe choice”. Perhaps this is culturally driven.
Where this gets interesting is when you switch it from the manufacturer’s cultural bias to the buyer’s motivation. Many buyers of Toyota Camrys are not knowledgeable about cars, they buy a Camry because Consumer Reports tells them to, they want to avoid a mistake. (Even though a car enthusiast’s magazine like Road and Track might view the Camry as boring and mediocre).
In contrast, a BMW or Cadillac ad usually emphasizes style and performance, as the people in the market for such cars have the self-esteem to chose the car that fits their individual wants and needs.
This suggests that car manufacturers should consider whether their target market buyer is knowledgeable enough to respond to self-enhacement advertising pitches, or insecure enough to require the “safe choice” style of ad. For example, if Chevrolet is trying to lure Camry buyers, they ought to assure them that buying a new Malibu is every bit as “safe” and “smart” as buying a Camry.