Plus: a warning about women’s representation
November 18, 2026  ·  View in browser
The Insightful Leader
BY KELLOGG INSIGHT
Leadership advice from the Kellogg School of Management at Northwestern University

Good morning,

Who will host? Who will bring the pie? How long will the in-laws stay? As Thanksgiving nears, many of us are engaging in the year’s most-elaborate negotiation, without even realizing we’re doing it. Yet the best negotiation strategy may land you the pie assignment you want. 

This week, Kellogg’s Victoria Medvec explains why it pays to speak first. Then, Thomas Lys shows how widening your view of what’s negotiable can help you find solutions the other side hadn’t even considered.

First dibs

It can be difficult to take the initiative in a negotiation. But research has shown that when we make the first move, we often get better outcomes, according to Medvec, a professor of management and organizations and the executive director of the Center for Executive Women.

That’s not to suggest that we should jump the gun. When we’re being considered for a job, for instance, we should not start negotiating until after we’ve been offered the position. But when an employer expresses interest in hiring us and wants to discuss what it will take, we “would absolutely want to speak first,” Medvec writes.  

Going first enables us to enhance our relationship with the other side, whereas being the responder puts us in a relationship-damaging position, since we’d likely need to critique or adjust the initiator’s first offer. 

Medvec offers an example. Let’s say someone is being considered to lead a major initiative at their company. They know that this initiative will require strong leadership and internal and external buy-in. So they take the first step in the negotiation and explain that in order to have enough credibility, it is essential that their title be upgraded to vice president. They also initiate a discussion of the timeline for the project, key success metrics, and a salary consistent with the vice-president role. 

“When you can lead, you want to lead; you will gain an advantage by creating the starting point, putting the right issues on the table, and being the one who frames the rationale,” Medvec writes.

Beyond your own plate

We all walk into a negotiation with expectations about what’s possible, and some of them may be holding us back. 

“It’s a good idea to broaden your perspective about what is negotiable,” says Lys, a professor emeritus of accounting information and management, “and to think about how your expectations influence your behavior.” 

One common roadblock is what Lys calls “confirmation bias”—the deceptive sense that we already know most of what we need to know: what the issues are, what our counterpart wants, and how the process is likely to proceed.

“One mistake people make is that when they analyze a situation, they only analyze the situation from their own perspective,” he says. “They spend very little time analyzing their counterpart’s perspective—not just from a rational perspective, but also from a psychological perspective.”  

When diplomats get together to discuss the terms of a cease-fire, for example, they always have to ask themselves: Is this a deal that the other side can even entertain? Do I really know what they want?

Lys says most people are too focused on just getting the negotiation over with. Yet negotiators who “come out of the gates swinging” often make the negotiation more adversarial than it needs to be and leave value on the table. 

“You shouldn’t think of a negotiation as a zero-sum game,” he says. “You should think about it like solving a problem—there may be more than one solution.” 

Read more about negotiation strategies in Kellogg Insight.

“It’s an important warning that women’s representation doesn’t necessarily mean changing the gendered division of work.”

— Jillian Chown, on LinkedIn, discussing how women physicians are taking on an increasingly disproportionate share of communication-intensive patient consultations.

Follow us on LinkedIn.
And listen to our podcasts.