Hangover after the Tax Holiday
Skip to content
Policy Finance & Accounting Jan 1, 2012

Hangover after the Tax Holiday

Little foreign income repatriated due to American Jobs Creation Act of 2004

Based on the research of

Thomas J. Brennan

Foreign subsidiaries of U.S. firms distributed more than $300 billion in dividends to their parent companies during the “tax holiday” created by the American Jobs Creation Act of 2004 (AJCA). But the true value of this short-term achievement must be considered in the light of its long-term effects, according to Thomas J. Brennan, an associate professor of finance at the Kellogg School of Management. His recent analysis shows that in the years since the holiday, the earnings returned from foreign subsidiaries to the United States have been largely offset by increased new investment of foreign earnings overseas.

Add Insight
to your inbox.

Furthermore, when Congress enacts a temporary tax holiday, it can have a permanent conditioning effect on corporate behavior, Brennan points out. Corporate decision-makers salivate for the next goodie that lawmakers are willing to serve up, and they arrange their affairs accordingly. In his research, Brennan found that an increased amount of the cash stashed overseas seems to have been relabeled as being permanently invested overseas. Relabeling funds is an expedient way for companies to prepare for a future repatriation tax holiday without substantially changing their behavior.

“The possibility of a future holiday leads to an incoherent kind of system. We say that we have a tax on foreign earnings when they come back to the U.S., but it is really very ineffective,” Brennan says.

Luring Money Back Home

Currently, he explains, profits made by a foreign subsidiary of a U.S. company are taxed in the foreign jurisdiction, and usually no tax is due in the United States until a dividend is paid from the subsidiary to the parent. This may motivate companies with subsidiaries in low-tax jurisdictions to keep foreign earnings abroad. In addition, any sums permanently reinvested in the foreign subsidiary can avoid not only current U.S. taxation but also the reporting of a deferred tax liability for financial accounting purposes. These taxation and accounting rules have provided part of the motivation for U.S. companies to keep an enormous amount of cash overseas.

The intent of Congress in passing the AJCA was to lure some of this money back stateside. The AJCA temporarily reduced the tax rate on repatriated dividends by 85 percent. In the short term, the $300 billion in repatriated funds makes it look as though Congress accomplished its goal.

“It is hard to know what the right solution is, but it is interesting that the U.S. is out of step with the rest of the world right now.”

However, the long-term data tell a different tale. Using statistical regression techniques, Brennan analyzed publicly available data about the post-AJCA overseas investment behavior of corporations that repatriated large amounts of cash under the Act. He found that these firms have increased the quantity of foreign earnings that they permanently reinvest abroad (Figure 1). Permanently reinvested earnings of the sample firms increased annually from about $100 billion in 1998 to about $400 billion just before the repatriation period. Subsequent to the repatriation window, permanently reinvested earnings for the sample firms steadily increased until they totaled about $600 billion in 2008.

Brennan2010_Fig1.gifFigure 1. Aggregated permanently reinvested earnings (PRE) for firms in the sample, 1998–2008. Repatriated funds placed in the column corresponding to the 2005 fiscal year.

Brennan explains that the problems illustrated by the AJCA are part of a bigger problem in the overall approach to corporate taxation. “This set of laws is badly dysfunctional in a way that is highlighted by the escapade of the 2004 repatriation and the subsequent machinations by corporations in response to it,” he says.

Other Options for Taxing Foreign Earnings

Various alternative approaches could be taken to taxation of foreign earnings, according to Brennan. One would be simply not to tax income that is earned in foreign countries, ever. This is the approach taken by most of the rest of the industrialized world. Brennan says that the current approach in the United States—referred to as worldwide taxation—used to be shared by many other countries, but gradually everyone changed except the United States. He notes, “It is hard to know what the right solution is, but it is interesting that the U.S. is out of step with the rest of the world right now.”

At the other extreme, the nation could impose an immediate tax on foreign earnings, with no deferral. However, this approach would put U.S. companies at a competitive disadvantage when operating internationally. Brennan says there are various compromise approaches Congress could take if it wants to find a middle ground. For example, foreign income could be taxed on a permanent basis at a reduced rate without deferral. He notes that this approach would remove the incentive to keep money invested overseas.

Brennan points out that the data on money repatriated under the AJCA provides a unique opportunity to study corporate behavior. “It is very rare that you have hundreds of billions of dollars moving around and then have the opportunity to see what the companies did with it.”

Partially in response to that data, Congress is trying to tailor its proposals a little more narrowly this time, according to Brennan. “Lawmakers must exercise care in weighing not only the short-term intended consequences but also the long-term behavioral changes induced by the prospect of future holidays. In the case of the AJCA tax holiday, these long-term effects were substantial and perhaps outweighed the short-term benefits, resulting in a net policy failure—at least to the extent that the policy goal was the long-term net return of foreign earnings to the United States.”

Congress is presently under pressure from the corporate community to provide another tax holiday, Brennan says. He believes that even if legislators learn from the mistakes made in the AJCA, the bottom line is that they should not enact additional tax holidays. “They should just make up their minds about how they want to tax foreign earnings, or not tax them. Then have that be the rule permanently.”

Related reading on Kellogg Insight

Big Tax Breaks Beget Small Investments: Why the American Jobs Creation Act lowered taxes but failed to spur domestic investment

Driven Offshore: An unintended consequence of Sarbanes-Oxley

Featured Faculty

Associate Professor of Finance (courtesy) and Associate Professor of Law

About the Writer
Beverly A. Caley, JD is an independent writer based in Corvallis, Oregon, who concentrates on business, legal, and science topics.
About the Research

Brennan, Thomas J. 2010. “What Happens After a Holiday? Long-Term Effects of the Repatriation Provision of the AJCA.” Northwestern Journal of Law and Social Policy. 5: 1-18.

Read the original

Most Popular This Week
  1. What Happens to Worker Productivity after a Minimum Wage Increase?
    A pay raise boosts productivity for some—but the impact on the bottom line is more complicated.
    employees unload pallets from a truck using hand carts
  2. 6 Takeaways on Inflation and the Economy Right Now
    Are we headed into a recession? Kellogg’s Sergio Rebelo breaks down the latest trends.
    inflatable dollar sign tied down with mountains in background
  3. How to Get the Ear of Your CEO—And What to Say When You Have It
    Every interaction with the top boss is an audition for senior leadership.
    employee presents to CEO in elevator
  4. 3 Tips for Reinventing Your Career After a Layoff
    It’s crucial to reassess what you want to be doing instead of jumping at the first opportunity.
    woman standing confidently
  5. How Offering a Product for Free Can Backfire
    It seems counterintuitive, but there are times customers would rather pay a small amount than get something for free.
    people in grocery store aisle choosing cheap over free option of same product.
  6. Which Form of Government Is Best?
    Democracies may not outlast dictatorships, but they adapt better.
    Is democracy the best form of government?
  7. When Do Open Borders Make Economic Sense?
    A new study provides a window into the logic behind various immigration policies.
    How immigration affects the economy depends on taxation and worker skills.
  8. Why Do Some People Succeed after Failing, While Others Continue to Flounder?
    A new study dispels some of the mystery behind success after failure.
    Scientists build a staircase from paper
  9. How Are Black–White Biracial People Perceived in Terms of Race?
    Understanding the answer—and why black and white Americans may percieve biracial people differently—is increasingly important in a multiracial society.
    How are biracial people perceived in terms of race
  10. How Has Marketing Changed over the Past Half-Century?
    Phil Kotler’s groundbreaking textbook came out 55 years ago. Sixteen editions later, he and coauthor Alexander Chernev discuss how big data, social media, and purpose-driven branding are moving the field forward.
    people in 1967 and 2022 react to advertising
  11. College Campuses Are Becoming More Diverse. But How Much Do Students from Different Backgrounds Actually Interact?
    Increasing diversity has been a key goal, “but far less attention is paid to what happens after we get people in the door.”
    College quad with students walking away from the center
  12. What Went Wrong at AIG?
    Unpacking the insurance giant's collapse during the 2008 financial crisis.
    What went wrong during the AIG financial crisis?
  13. Immigrants to the U.S. Create More Jobs than They Take
    A new study finds that immigrants are far more likely to found companies—both large and small—than native-born Americans.
    Immigrant CEO welcomes new hires
  14. Podcast: Does Your Life Reflect What You Value?
    On this episode of The Insightful Leader, a former CEO explains how to organize your life around what really matters—instead of trying to do it all.
  15. How Peer Pressure Can Lead Teens to Underachieve—Even in Schools Where It’s “Cool to Be Smart”
    New research offers lessons for administrators hoping to improve student performance.
    Eager student raises hand while other student hesitates.
  16. Why Well-Meaning NGOs Sometimes Do More Harm than Good
    Studies of aid groups in Ghana and Uganda show why it’s so important to coordinate with local governments and institutions.
    To succeed, foreign aid and health programs need buy-in and coordination with local partners.
  17. How Will Automation Affect Different U.S. Cities?
    Jobs in small cities will likely be hit hardest. Check how your community and profession will fare.
    How will automation affect jobs and cities?
More in Policy