How Do People Respond to Sales Tax Increases?
Skip to content
Economics Finance & Accounting Policy Nov 2, 2017

How Do People Respond to Sales Tax Increases?

New research shows we aren’t as blasé as economists thought.

Lisa Röper

Based on the research of

Scott R. Baker

Stephanie Johnson

Lorenz Kueng

What makes for a “good” tax? From the point of view of government policymakers, a good tax raises a lot of money without causing people to avoid the tax by distorting their spending (or voting) behavior.

Add Insight
to your inbox.

By that measure, a sales tax is a very good tax indeed: a body of research shows that, overall, sales-tax rates are not noticeable enough to consumers to make them change their behavior. In other words, we tend to adopt an attitude of “it is what it is” about sales tax—even when the rates go up—and just get on with the business of purchasing what we need.

But most of what we understand about how people respond to sales taxes comes from observing national consumer spending in aggregate and looking at changes on an annual basis. New research from the Kellogg school explores whether individual households are really so blasé about the government-mandated markups at the cash register.

“You know, we’re Americans—we don’t like paying taxes,” quips assistant finance professor Scott Baker.

Zooming In

Baker, along with assistant finance professor Lorenz Kueng and Stephanie Johnson, a graduate student at Northwestern University’s department of economics, wanted to put consumers’ responses to sales-tax changes, “under a microscope,” as Kueng puts it.

“It’s only when you’re able to zoom in on an actual month that you can actually see a very clear, very stark pattern of change in the way individual households spend their money.” —Scott Baker

Using data from the Nielsen Consumer Panel and Thomson Reuters, the researchers assembled a month-by-month timeline of consumer-spending choices from more than 150,000 households across the U.S. The database included purchases at grocery, pharmacy, and mass-merchandise stores, averaging about $350 per month per household. The researchers then matched the data against changes to local sales-tax rates in 41,250 ZIP codes between 2008 and 2014.

“We could measure very precisely what tax rates these households were subject to and when,” Baker says. Additionally, “you can tell if they bought the 20-ounce bottle of Coke or the two-liter bottle.”

This highly specific data matters because some products are tax-exempt in certain ZIP codes, while others are not. For example, most grocery items are exempt from local sales tax, while toys and tools are almost always taxed; clothing or prepared food, meanwhile, may or may not be subject to sales tax depending on where it is purchased.

The authors compiled additional data to examine what they call “the fiscal implementation lag”: the time between when the public learns about an upcoming sales-tax increase and when it actually is implemented.

To measure this lag, the authors scoured 3,000 U.S. newspapers from 2008 and 2016 for mentions of “sales tax” or “sales taxes,” analyzed Google search data to measure the frequency of relevant search terms like “sales tax,” and identified state-ballot items that proposed a change to local tax policy.

When all the numbers were crunched, it turned out that traditional wisdom on the impact of sales-tax rates held—but only when looking long term.

The researchers saw no impact on household spending habits four months to a year after a sales-tax increase. But when they focused their “microscope” down to the month immediately before the change, as well as the month immediately after, they found that “all this anticipatory action occurs,” Baker says. “It’s only when you’re able to zoom in on an actual month that you can actually see a very clear, very stark pattern of change in the way individual households spend their money.”

Shifting Costs to Avoid Sales Taxes

The clearest impact that the researchers observed will sound familiar to anyone who has changed their shopping plans to take advantage of a sale.

“Households in the month before the tax increase tend to stock up,” Kueng says. “And then there’s a kind of a mirror image decline in consumption in the following month” when the increased sales tax comes into effect.

“This seems to be most consistent,” he says, “with a story that they were time-shifting their purchases”—that is, buying next month’s goods ahead of time to avoid the tax.

Other findings made intuitive sense, as well.

For example, the “stocking up” effect on consumption was four times greater when the authors focused their analysis on nonperishable goods. “There’s much more of an effect if you’re looking at T-shirts, small electronics, laundry detergent—anything durable or easily storable,” Kueng says.

Crossing state lines to avoid sales taxes also increased among households located in ZIP codes where such movement is physically convenient.

“If you live in a part of Chicago that’s near Wisconsin or near Indiana, you might shift across the border if there are lower sales taxes there,” Kueng says.

Online shopping spiked upwards following a local increase in sales tax, too, likely because few consumers pay the additional sales tax, called a “use tax,” that they are supposed to pay on goods bought out of state at a lower sales-tax rate, Baker says.

Taking pains to avoid paying a few extra cents of sales tax might sound pointlessly frugal, but it struck Baker and Kueng as eminently reasonable behavior for the average price-sensitive, tax-phobic American household.

“The effect isn’t huge,” Kueng says. “But if you compare it to how people respond to ordinary price changes or store sales, it’s in the same ballpark. It’s definitely not crazy.”

A Surprising Effect of a Sales-Tax Increase

One result, however, caught the researchers by surprise.

They found that during the “stocking up” phase in the month before a sales-tax increase, households did not just buy more taxable goods—they stocked up on tax-exempt items, too.

This seemed irrational: Why would consumers bother to do this time-shifting for goods whose cost will not change over time?

“That was probably the most surprising result that we found,” Kueng says.

One potential explanation: consumers simply don’t know any better. “The idea is that they are just confused—they don’t know which goods are tax-exempt and which goods are taxable,” Kueng says.

But the researchers wondered if, instead, this seemingly irrational spending behavior might actually be an optimal response to the practical realities of shopping.

“The only reason a ‘shopping trip’ actually exists is because it’s kind of costly to go to the store under any circumstances: you have to get in your car, use gasoline, wait in lines, all that stuff,” Baker explains. “And so if you’re already out there getting extra things that you know will be more expensive a month from now, you might as well pick up a few other things that you might be close to running out of too, even if they’re not going to be affected by the sales tax. It’s still less costly than making a separate trip later.”

In other words, households may know the difference between taxable and tax-exempt goods—they just know that shopping trips are a pain, too. And so stocking up on both categories of items at once in order to keep those costly trips to a minimum might be rational economic behavior after all.

Under this theory, it follows that shopping trips with no fixed costs—like buying goods online instead of in a store—would not show the same kind of “stocking up” effect for taxable and tax-exempt items at the same time.

“And that is exactly what we found,” Kueng says.

Is It a Good Tax?

So if individual households notice and respond to the sales tax in the month before and after a rate change, does that mean it’s a “good” tax—or not?

“If you don’t want taxes distorting how people spend, it appears that in the short run, sales tax is distortionary,” Baker says. “But that may also be a desirable policy outcome.”

He cites the Cash for Clunkers program in the U.S.—in which consumers were given vouchers for trading in aging vehicles, which could be applied to lower the cost of purchasing a newer, more fuel-efficient vehicle—as an example of this “desirable distortion.” The program provided a cash infusion into the auto industry by shifting car purchases forward in time, while also getting some inefficient vehicles off the road.

Intentional time-shifting of purchases could even function “as a kind of stimulus package,” Baker adds. “For groceries and pharmacy items, we find that the effect is relatively short-lived on average. But the more storable and durable the product, the longer the effect of a sales-tax change on the economy. For larger durables like furniture or cars, we would expect even larger effects that would last for a couple of quarters or years.”

And, when zooming the microscope back out, Baker says, “the tax is also good in the sense that, in the longer run, it doesn’t seem to be very distortionary.”

About the Writer
John Pavlus is a writer and filmmaker focusing on science, technology, and design topics. He lives in Portland, Oregon.
About the Research
Baker, Scott R., Stephanie Johnson, and Lorenz Kueng. 2017. “Shopping for Lower Sales Tax Rates.” Working paper.

Read the original

Most Popular This Week
  1. Will AI Eventually Replace Doctors?
    Maybe not entirely. But the doctor–patient relationship is likely to change dramatically.
    doctors offices in small nodules
  2. 3 Tips for Reinventing Your Career After a Layoff
    It’s crucial to reassess what you want to be doing instead of jumping at the first opportunity.
    woman standing confidently
  3. What Happens to Worker Productivity after a Minimum Wage Increase?
    A pay raise boosts productivity for some—but the impact on the bottom line is more complicated.
    employees unload pallets from a truck using hand carts
  4. 6 Takeaways on Inflation and the Economy Right Now
    Are we headed into a recession? Kellogg’s Sergio Rebelo breaks down the latest trends.
    inflatable dollar sign tied down with mountains in background
  5. What Is the Purpose of a Corporation Today?
    Has anything changed in the three years since the Business Roundtable declared firms should prioritize more than shareholders?
    A city's skyscrapers interspersed with trees and rooftop gardens
  6. How to Get the Ear of Your CEO—And What to Say When You Have It
    Every interaction with the top boss is an audition for senior leadership.
    employee presents to CEO in elevator
  7. Why We Can’t All Get Away with Wearing Designer Clothes
    In certain professions, luxury goods can send the wrong signal.​
    Man wearing luxury-brand clothes walks with a cold wind behind him, chilling three people he passes.
  8. Why You Should Skip the Easy Wins and Tackle the Hard Task First
    New research shows that you and your organization lose out when you procrastinate on the difficult stuff.
    A to-do list with easy and hard tasks
  9. How Are Black–White Biracial People Perceived in Terms of Race?
    Understanding the answer—and why black and white Americans may percieve biracial people differently—is increasingly important in a multiracial society.
    How are biracial people perceived in terms of race
  10. Which Form of Government Is Best?
    Democracies may not outlast dictatorships, but they adapt better.
    Is democracy the best form of government?
  11. When Do Open Borders Make Economic Sense?
    A new study provides a window into the logic behind various immigration policies.
    How immigration affects the economy depends on taxation and worker skills.
  12. Why Do Some People Succeed after Failing, While Others Continue to Flounder?
    A new study dispels some of the mystery behind success after failure.
    Scientists build a staircase from paper
  13. How Has Marketing Changed over the Past Half-Century?
    Phil Kotler’s groundbreaking textbook came out 55 years ago. Sixteen editions later, he and coauthor Alexander Chernev discuss how big data, social media, and purpose-driven branding are moving the field forward.
    people in 1967 and 2022 react to advertising
  14. How Old Are Successful Tech Entrepreneurs?
    A definitive new study dispels the myth of the Silicon Valley wunderkind.
    successful entrepreneurs are most often middle aged
  15. How Offering a Product for Free Can Backfire
    It seems counterintuitive, but there are times customers would rather pay a small amount than get something for free.
    people in grocery store aisle choosing cheap over free option of same product.
  16. Immigrants to the U.S. Create More Jobs than They Take
    A new study finds that immigrants are far more likely to found companies—both large and small—than native-born Americans.
    Immigrant CEO welcomes new hires
  17. College Campuses Are Becoming More Diverse. But How Much Do Students from Different Backgrounds Actually Interact?
    Increasing diversity has been a key goal, “but far less attention is paid to what happens after we get people in the door.”
    College quad with students walking away from the center
  18. How Peer Pressure Can Lead Teens to Underachieve—Even in Schools Where It’s “Cool to Be Smart”
    New research offers lessons for administrators hoping to improve student performance.
    Eager student raises hand while other student hesitates.
More in Economics