Hate Commercial Breaks? Here’s Why You Shouldn’t
Skip to content
Marketing Jul 1, 2016

Hate Com­mer­cial Breaks? Here’s Why You Shouldn’t

There’s a hid­den val­ue to ads dur­ing TV shows.

Commercial break allows television viewer to change channels.

Yevgenia Nayberg

Based on the research of

Song Yao

Yuxin Chen

Wenbo Wang

A famil­iar scene plays out in liv­ing rooms every night. You are absorbed in a TV show, when a jin­gle sig­nals the begin­ning of a com­mer­cial. To adver­tis­ers and tele­vi­sion chan­nels, the next few sec­onds are cru­cial: Do you see this as an oppor­tu­ni­ty to click to anoth­er chan­nel, or will you sit through the com­mer­cials? And if you leave the chan­nel, will you return after the com­mer­cials to con­tin­ue watch­ing your show?

Add Insight
to your inbox.

We’ll send you one email a week with content you actually want to read, curated by the Insight team.

The chance to grab mil­lions of eye­balls dur­ing prime­time shows dri­ves mar­keters to pay big bucks for sec­onds of air­time, cre­at­ing a rich source of income for chan­nels. But to view­ers, com­mer­cials can feel like an annoyance.

The con­ven­tion­al wis­dom of TV com­mer­cials is that con­sumers pre­fer non-dis­rupt­ed view­ing,” says Song Yao, assis­tant pro­fes­sor of mar­ket­ing at the Kel­logg School.

This line of think­ing might seem obvi­ous to Net­flix binge-watch­ers. And it was the rea­son why the Chi­nese gov­ern­ment insti­tut­ed a pol­i­cy in 2012 that pro­hib­it­ed com­mer­cial breaks dur­ing a show, rel­e­gat­ing TV adver­tis­ing to slots between shows. The government’s goal was to make the view­ing expe­ri­ence more enjoyable.

When we learned about this pol­i­cy, we start­ed think­ing about whether remov­ing com­mer­cials is always good for view­ers,” Yao says. It seemed ambigu­ous. It real­ly depends on what you are watch­ing when the com­mer­cial starts.”

Might com­mer­cials dur­ing shows actu­al­ly have an upside for view­ers? After all, they do present a break in the action, which per­haps view­ers appreciate.

Nor­mal­ly, we might say nobody likes a com­mer­cial, which is true. But it has some ben­e­fits from the viewer’s perspective.”

Yao, along with Wen­bo Wang at the Hong Kong Uni­ver­si­ty of Sci­ence and Tech­nol­o­gy and Yux­in Chen at New York Uni­ver­si­ty Shang­hai, set out to under­stand how com­mer­cials dur­ing a show affect­ed TV chan­nel view­er­ship. Their results are rel­e­vant to any com­pa­ny that has to decide how to time the release of prod­ucts with­in a spe­cif­ic line, from video games to Lego sets.

Sud­den Ad Change

Pri­or to 2012, com­mer­cial breaks on Chi­nese TV chan­nels were sim­i­lar to those in the U.S. Ads could be broad­cast both dur­ing a show and between shows. With­in-show slots were more valu­able from the per­spec­tive of adver­tis­ers, since it was assumed that view­ers were more like­ly to sit through the com­mer­cials in order to see the remain­der of the show they had been watching.

The Chi­nese pol­i­cy, which banned com­mer­cials with­in a show but not between shows, went into effect with only 40 days’ notice. Tak­en by sur­prise, adver­tis­ers were unable to change their pro­gram­ming because the admin­is­tra­tive review process imposed by the author­i­ties took at least 50 days.

So at that time, the only behav­ior that could be affect­ed by the pol­i­cy change was that of the view­ers in response to the reduc­tion of com­mer­cial time,” Yao says.

What hap­pened once with­in-show ads were removed? Were view­ers actu­al­ly bet­ter off?

Researchers gath­ered a vari­ety of infor­ma­tion from a few weeks before until a few weeks after the pol­i­cy change. This includ­ed minute-by-minute prime­time rat­ings for the top 29 chan­nels in Bei­jing, as well as house­hold-lev­el data from more than 1,000 set-top meters that record­ed what chan­nel peo­ple were watch­ing at any par­tic­u­lar minute and, for each one-minute inter­val, whether the chan­nels were broad­cast­ing a spe­cif­ic show or a com­mer­cial (either between or with­in shows).

This allowed the researchers to con­duct a giant exper­i­ment in rooms across the coun­try. How like­ly were peo­ple to click their remote but­tons in response to two dis­tinct sit­u­a­tions — when com­mer­cials were pre­sent­ed with­in a TV show, and when shows ran ad-free?

Hid­den Perks

The researchers learned that remov­ing ads cre­at­ed a bet­ter view­ing expe­ri­ence only some of the time. It all depend­ed on what chan­nel view­ers began to watch when they first turned on the TV.

View­ers who set­tled into their couch and turned on a high­ly rat­ed chan­nel were less like­ly to click away to anoth­er chan­nel. So for these indi­vid­u­als, the loss of with­in-show com­mer­cials — and the click­ing-around oppor­tu­ni­ty those present — was not prob­lem­at­ic since they were hap­py with what they were watch­ing. In fact, they were most­ly bet­ter off because now they could enjoy a high­ly rat­ed show with­out com­mer­cial interruptions.

But if it was a poor­ly rat­ed chan­nel — or sim­ply one the view­er did not par­tic­u­lar­ly care for — drop­ping the ads posed a prob­lem. Find­ing some­thing bet­ter to watch was now cost­lier” for view­ers, since any time spent explor­ing alter­na­tives now meant miss­ing out on the ongo­ing show, even though it was one they were not that enthused about watch­ing. In the past, of course, they could have been explor­ing alter­na­tive chan­nels dur­ing with­in-show com­mer­cial breaks.

Nor­mal­ly, we might say nobody likes a com­mer­cial, which is true. But it has some ben­e­fits from the viewer’s per­spec­tive,” Yao says. It gives you this nat­ur­al oppor­tu­ni­ty to explore; oth­er­wise, you’re stuck with what you’re watching.”

Even among view­ers who did click away, the same over­all find­ings emerged. View­ers watch­ing a high-rat­ed chan­nel who clicked away dur­ing an in-show com­mer­cial were more like­ly to switch back to that chan­nel after the ad, com­pared with those who start­ed on a low-rat­ed chan­nel. Those view­ers were more like­ly to stay on the high-rat­ed chan­nel if they switched there dur­ing an ad break, aban­don­ing the low­er-rat­ed show.

Keep­ing an Eye on Com­peti­tors’ Timing

How can chan­nels use this knowl­edge of view­ing behav­ior to attract — or sim­ply retain — their audi­ences? Tim­ing ad breaks care­ful­ly based on what your com­peti­tors are doing is the key to suc­cess, Yao explains.

Low­er-rat­ed chan­nels should look to mim­ic their com­pe­ti­tion. If low­er-rat­ed chan­nels syn­chro­nized their ad breaks with high-rat­ed com­peti­tors, the incen­tive for view­ers to leave the low­er-rat­ed chan­nels would be low­er: no mat­ter which chan­nel they choose, they know they will only see commercials.

The oppo­site is true for high-rat­ed chan­nels. They should try to dif­fer­en­ti­ate them­selves from oth­ers, Yao says. If they air an excit­ing episode while a com­peti­tor is on an ad break, their chance of poach­ing view­ers is high­er. Mean­while, when they are air­ing an ad while their com­peti­tors are not, their view­ers are less like­ly to click away. Even if they do, they will come back after the ad ends.

It is a dynam­ic deci­sion that needs to be made depend­ing on what kind of show your com­peti­tor has rel­a­tive to the qual­i­ty of your show,” Yao says.

Breaks with Benefits

The results pro­vide guid­ance for the tim­ing of adver­tise­ments on oth­er plat­forms than tele­vi­sion, such as radio. But in a broad­er sense, the study has impli­ca­tions for any kind of a pause in the avail­abil­i­ty of a prod­uct, Yao explains.

For exam­ple, video-game man­u­fac­tur­ers might ben­e­fit if they syn­chro­nize the release of new games, Yao sug­gests. High­ly pop­u­lar series, such as Fall­out or Call of Duty, are like­ly to gar­ner more play­ers if they are released at sep­a­rate times, so a play­er can focus on one at a time.

For mobile apps and games, where devel­op­ers release upgrades or new fea­tures peri­od­i­cal­ly, care­ful­ly tim­ing the breaks between such releas­es could help keep their audi­ences inter­est­ed. You need to have a break so cus­tomers can learn to use new fea­tures or play new lev­els of a game,” Yao says. But if the break is too long, con­sumers may get bored and look for alter­na­tives. Both the tim­ing of a break and the length of the break are important.”

From Lego sets to the Thomas the Tank Engine series, the same prin­ci­ples could apply to the release of lines of non-vir­tu­al toys and games as well.

For now, how­ev­er, Yao and his col­leagues are focused on test­ing their the­o­ry on Chi­nese TV chan­nels. They are work­ing with net­works to strate­gi­cal­ly man­age the tim­ing of their com­mer­cials to max­i­mize viewership.

But if low-ranked chan­nels syn­chro­nize their com­mer­cials and high­er-ranked ones race to keep theirs apart, who wins? It depends on who makes the first move,” Yao says. The mar­ket will end up with some kind of mix — but what equi­lib­ri­um it might reach remains to be seen.”

Featured Faculty

Song Yao

Member of the Department of Marketing faculty until 2017

<p>&nbsp;</p>

About the Writer

Jyoti Madhusoodanan is a Bay Area-based science writer.

About the Research

Yao, Song, Yuxin Chen, and Wenbo Wang. 2015. “Channel Search and Welfare Implications of Commercial Breaks.” Working paper.

Read the original

Suggested For You

Most Popular

Organizations

How Are Black – White Bira­cial Peo­ple Per­ceived in Terms of Race?

Under­stand­ing the answer — and why black and white Amer­i­cans’ respons­es may dif­fer — is increas­ing­ly impor­tant in a mul­tira­cial society.

Careers

Pod­cast: Our Most Pop­u­lar Advice on Advanc­ing Your Career

Here’s how to con­nect with head­hunters, deliv­er with data, and ensure you don’t plateau professionally.

Most Popular Podcasts

Careers

Pod­cast: Our Most Pop­u­lar Advice on Improv­ing Rela­tion­ships with Colleagues

Cowork­ers can make us crazy. Here’s how to han­dle tough situations.

Social Impact

Pod­cast: How You and Your Com­pa­ny Can Lend Exper­tise to a Non­prof­it in Need

Plus: Four ques­tions to con­sid­er before becom­ing a social-impact entrepreneur.

Careers

Pod­cast: Attract Rock­star Employ­ees — or Devel­op Your Own

Find­ing and nur­tur­ing high per­form­ers isn’t easy, but it pays off.

Marketing

Pod­cast: How Music Can Change Our Mood

A Broad­way song­writer and a mar­ket­ing pro­fes­sor dis­cuss the con­nec­tion between our favorite tunes and how they make us feel.