Tort Reform No Miracle Cure
Skip to content
Policy Strategy Economics Oct 1, 2009

Tort Reform No Miracle Cure

Limiting liability has limited impact on healthcare costs

Based on the research of

Ronen Avraham

Leemore S. Dafny

Max M. Schanzenbach

The lawyers can relax. There’s no need to follow Shakespeare’s advice to kill them after all.

In fact, when assessing out-of-control U.S. healthcare costs, malpractice and related litigation are just “a drop in the bucket,” according to Kellogg School Assistant Professor of Management and Strategy Leemore Dafny.

“These costs, all told, have been estimated to be only about 2 percent of healthcare expenses,” says Dafny, an economist and expert in healthcare competition.

Her own research, drawn from various “demonstration projects” already implemented at the state level, indicates that the most common legal reforms would collectively reduce health insurance premiums by 2 percent. This is “real money,” she admits, given that private insurance premiums now top $800 billion, but still no “silver bullet” solution to the overall healthcare crisis.

The data appear in “The Impact of Tort Reform on Health Insurance Premiums,” a new working paper she has co-authored with Ronen Avraham and Max Schanzenbach, colleagues from Northwestern University’s School of Law. The research evaluates the effect of tort reform on employer-sponsored health insurance premiums of more than 10 million Americans annually between 1998 and 2006.

Quick fix unlikely
Dafny’s findings offer little cheer to anyone seeking a quick legal fix to the challenge of making healthcare more widely affordable.

“This is a very long-term problem and it’s going to take quite a while to see any appreciable difference unless we have some major and drastic reforms,” says Dafny, adding that even some of the proposals that President Barack Obama outlined in his Sept. 9 national address on healthcare would require four years to phase in. “It sounds like a long time, but these things take a long time,” she says.

The ideal — and exceedingly difficult — goal of healthcare reform is to vastly expand coverage to include an estimated 46 million Americans currently without health insurance while simultaneously reducing costs. Some, including President Obama, have considered legal reforms as one way to help make the numbers add up. Dafny’s research suggests that this line of thinking is unlikely to produce anything other than a very modest advantage.

Tort reform — changes to the legal system that, in the case of healthcare, would limit the liability damages of physicians and insurance companies — has been a perennial hot-button issue. Some have argued that such reform would reduce the threat of liability that can drive doctors to prescribe tests and procedures that may not be medically required, but which keep the patient happy and safeguard the practitioner against lawsuits. Tort reform advocates have long argued that this “defensive medicine” contributes to the overall cost burden in the healthcare system without providing much real benefit.

But until now little aggregate empirical data existed to support the claims of either tort reform proponents or detractors. Dafny’s research clearly shows that such reforms would be limited.

“Tort reform’s impact is significant — meaning we can measure it — but significant and small,” says Dafny, who has been among the economic experts talking with senior members of the Obama administration to share research-based recommendations about the best way to improve the nation’s healthcare system. “To the extent that defensive medicine is driving up costs, malpractice reform is not going to curb it very much.”

So what is more likely to have a bigger impact on fixing healthcare? Dafny believes several pieces are critical, including creating incentives that encourage stakeholders to be more aware of cost, which in turn should lead to more thrifty behavior. One possibility is to mandate the purchase of insurance through a regulated exchange. Households choosing less generous coverage would pocket the savings, and the government could provide income-based subsidies. All would be required to have a certain minimum package of benefits. Even this scenario, though, presents challenges, Dafny says: “What we consider a ‘minimum of care’ is still going to be costly to provide.”

Looking elsewhere
Ultimately, she says, fixing the system will require a shift in expectations.

“I think Americans will have to come to accept more limits, more gatekeepers, more utilization review than they have in the past,” Dafny says. “We’ve been content to say that 46 million people don’t have any coverage and the rest of us have everything.”

Bringing those uninsured on board is “untenable,” she adds, if we expect to provide them with the type of care enjoyed by the currently insured.

As the healthcare debate continues, Dafny’s research is part of the discussion. With malpractice reform being such a hot topic, she says it’s important to consider the hard data.

“So many people have blown out of proportion the impact that tort reform could have,” Dafny says. “Now we know. We&rrsquo;ve done some tests and it turns out that it’s not going to be a huge fix. We’ve got to look at something else.”

Featured Faculty

Member of the Department of Strategy from 2002-2016

About the Writer
Matt Golosinski, Executive Editor, Marketing & Communications, Kellogg School of Management
About the Research

Avraham, Ronen, Leemore S. Dafny and Max M. Schanzenbach. 2012. “The Impact of Tort Reform on Employer-Sponsored Health Insurance Premiums,” Journal of Law, Economics & Organization, 28(4): 657-686.

Read the original

Most Popular This Week
  1. How Much Do Boycotts Affect a Company’s Bottom Line?
    There’s often an opposing camp pushing for a “buycott” to support the company. New research shows which group has more sway.
    grocery store aisle where two groups of people protest. One group is boycotting, while the other is buycotting
  2. 5 Takeaways on the State of ESG Investing
    ESG investing is hot. But what does it actually deliver for society and for shareholders?
    watering can pouring over windmills
  3. Could Bringing Your "Whole Self" to Work Curb Unethical Behavior?
    Organizations would be wise to help employees avoid compartmentalizing their personal and professional identities.
    A star employee brings her whole self to work.
  4. When Do Open Borders Make Economic Sense?
    A new study provides a window into the logic behind various immigration policies.
    How immigration affects the economy depends on taxation and worker skills.
  5. Which Form of Government Is Best?
    Democracies may not outlast dictatorships, but they adapt better.
    Is democracy the best form of government?
  6. How Has Marketing Changed over the Past Half-Century?
    Phil Kotler’s groundbreaking textbook came out 55 years ago. Sixteen editions later, he and coauthor Alexander Chernev discuss how big data, social media, and purpose-driven branding are moving the field forward.
    people in 1967 and 2022 react to advertising
  7. What Happens to Worker Productivity after a Minimum Wage Increase?
    A pay raise boosts productivity for some—but the impact on the bottom line is more complicated.
    employees unload pallets from a truck using hand carts
  8. Why Do Some People Succeed after Failing, While Others Continue to Flounder?
    A new study dispels some of the mystery behind success after failure.
    Scientists build a staircase from paper
  9. 3 Tips for Reinventing Your Career After a Layoff
    It’s crucial to reassess what you want to be doing instead of jumping at the first opportunity.
    woman standing confidently
  10. What Went Wrong at AIG?
    Unpacking the insurance giant's collapse during the 2008 financial crisis.
    What went wrong during the AIG financial crisis?
  11. Podcast: Does Your Life Reflect What You Value?
    On this episode of The Insightful Leader, a former CEO explains how to organize your life around what really matters—instead of trying to do it all.
  12. Why Well-Meaning NGOs Sometimes Do More Harm than Good
    Studies of aid groups in Ghana and Uganda show why it’s so important to coordinate with local governments and institutions.
    To succeed, foreign aid and health programs need buy-in and coordination with local partners.
  13. Your Team Doesn’t Need You to Be the Hero
    Too many leaders instinctively try to fix a crisis themselves. A U.S. Army colonel explains how to curb this tendency in yourself and allow your teams to flourish.
    person with red cape trying to put out fire while firefighters stand by.
  14. Immigrants to the U.S. Create More Jobs than They Take
    A new study finds that immigrants are far more likely to found companies—both large and small—than native-born Americans.
    Immigrant CEO welcomes new hires
  15. How Are Black–White Biracial People Perceived in Terms of Race?
    Understanding the answer—and why black and white Americans may percieve biracial people differently—is increasingly important in a multiracial society.
    How are biracial people perceived in terms of race
  16. In a World of Widespread Video Sharing, What’s Real and What’s Not?
    A discussion with a video-authentication expert on what it takes to unearth “deepfakes.”
    A detective pulls back his computer screen to reveal code behind the video image.
More in Policy