How to talk politics (constructively)
Skip to content
This website uses cookies and similar technologies to analyze and optimize site usage. By continuing to use our websites, you consent to this. For more information, please read our Privacy Statement.
The Insightful Leader Logo The Insightful Leader Sent to subscribers on October 2, 2024
How to talk politics (constructively)

Good morning,

For many of us, the thought of talking politics is about as appealing as getting a root canal. In a deeply divided America, delving into political discussion doesn’t seem to have much point.

But Kellogg research suggests it can be worth doing—and it’s possible to approach political conversations in a healthy and constructive way. This week, we’ll discuss one tactic that may help.

Plus: Is your boss planning to cut your marketing budget again? You need a better plan.

Use science-based strategies to put aside your preconceived notions of “the other side”

It’s not just your imagination. Something really has changed in American politics, says Eli J. Finkel, a professor of management and organizations. Over the past five years in particular, “the two sides have grown to hate each other so much.”

In a study, Finkel and coauthors examined 200 academic publications in hopes of understanding what’s at the heart of this newfound antagonism and what we can do about it.

One important discovery: the problem is less political polarization and more partisan animosity. It turns out the average liberal and conservative haven’t gotten farther apart in how they think about key political issues, but they have grown to dislike one another much more than they once did. In the 1970s, when pollsters asked voters to rate from zero to 100 their feelings about the average supporter of the opposing party, “you’d get something in the middle of the scale, about 50. Today, it’s closer to about 20,” Finkel says. In other words, we’re not having an issues problem—we’re having a feelings problem that masquerades as a fight over policy.

This may explain why some of the most promising interventions to reduce partisan animosity the researchers identified focused on correcting misperceptions. For example, one study found that Republicans and Democrats overestimated the extent to which the other side dehumanized them—by as much as 300 percent. Correcting such misperceptions, other research has found, can reduce rates of animosity.

Similarly, several studies found that exposure to political opponents’ personal experiences, as well as thoughtful arguments for their positions, softened people’s views of them.

“We don’t hate the other side because we understand what they stand for,” Finkel says. “We hate the other side because we have fabricated villains, misperceiving the average political opponent as a caricatured zealot.”

For more strategies on constructive political conversations, visit Kellogg Insight.

The Insightful Leader Live: AI Isn’t Magic—It’s Hard Work. Here’s How to Get Started.

AI isn’t going to magically boost profits or make your employees more productive. In fact, in the short term, it will probably make your organization less productive. But that doesn’t mean you should ignore everything these powerful systems have to offer. Instead, it’s important to be realistic about what they can do for you and strategic about how and where to use them. In this complimentary webinar, Kellogg’s Hatim Rahman and McCormick’s Elizabeth Gerber will go beyond the hype, sharing concrete information that will help you navigate some of the biggest challenges of adopting AI. They’ll discuss everything from data collection and model training to the broader cultural and human-capital shifts required of any company that wants to use AI effectively.

The webinar is next Thursday, October 10, 12 PM – 1 PM Central. Register here. We’d love to see you!

“If you had what looks like a bill to your CFO, they naturally think about ways to trim it.”

Jim Lecinski, in Think with Google, on how to develop an annual marketing plan that positions you as a revenue driver rather than a cost center.

Jessica Love, editor in chief
Kellogg Insight

Laura Pavin, multimedia editor
Kellogg Insight

close-thin