Take 5: What's in Your Investment Portfolio?
Skip to content
Finance & Accounting Jun 7, 2018

Take 5: What’s in Your Investment Portfolio?

Here’s what our faculty have to say about assessing new stocks, investing in green companies—and the benefits of benign neglect.

An origami hummingbird represents social impact investment strategies.

Lisa Röper

Ever wondered whether your favorite investment tool actually works? Or what research has to say about the benefits of benignly neglecting your portfolio? Or why investors are looking closely at companies’ track records for sustainability?

In this collection of articles, our faculty discuss various aspects of investing. Read on—because an informed investor is a good investor.

1. Your Investment Tool Is Failing You

The Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM) is the most commonly used tool for predicting stock returns for individual firms. Unfortunately, it doesn’t work, says Kellogg assistant professor of accounting information and management Matthew Lyle. Fortunately, he and his coauthor have come up with one that does.

The CAPM model focuses on how sensitive a stock price is to the broader market. “The biggest insight CAPM delivers is that the more exposure a stock has to market-wide upturns and downturns—the more the risk—the higher the expected stock return will be,” Lyle explains. However, after testing CAPM against data from the 1970s to 2013, the researchers found no evidence of its predictive powers.

The model they came up with uses accounting fundamentals instead: namely, a firm’s stock returns, its book-to-market ratio, and its return on equity. The researchers tested their model using the same data against which they had tested the CAPM model. They found that their new model—which they say is relatively easy for any investor to adopt—could robustly forecast stock returns up to three years into the future.

Add Insight
to your inbox.

We’ll send you one email a week with content you actually want to read, curated by the Insight team.

2. Learn from “One of the Investment Greats”

How does Louis Simpson approach investing?

Called “one of the investment greats” by Warren Buffett, Simpson is former chief investment officer for Geico and current Chairman of SQ Advisors. He is also a senior fellow and adjunct professor of finance at Kellogg, a member of Northwestern University’s Board of Trustees, and a member of the Advisory Council of Kellogg’s Asset Management Practicum.

Simpson discusses his remarkably successful investment strategy in an interview with Robert Korajczyk, a professor of finance at Kellogg.

“You can only know so many companies,” says Simpson. “If you’re managing 50 or 100 positions, the chances that you can add value are much, much lower.”

Read the rest of the interview here.

3. Don’t Look Now

Why put off till tomorrow what you can do today? Because, according to Kellogg finance professor Janice Eberly, you may get a better return on your investments that way.

Eberly and her colleagues have conducted research suggesting that investors who closely monitor their portfolios may be shooting themselves in the foot. That’s because the more you monitor your portfolio, the more likely you are to make changes to it—and, of course, there are costs associated with those changes.

So what does their research say about how often investors should check their portfolios? Even when costs represent only 0.01 percent of total wealth, the optimal inattention time is nearly eight months. As costs go up, that optimal inattention period does also.

Optimal inattention time is also affected by the rate of return on investment. For example, because less aggressive portfolios will de facto grow more slowly, they need to be optimized less often—whereas riskier portfolios with higher rates of return should be adjusted at more frequent intervals.

“I think of it as the optimality of procrastination,” Eberly says of her findings. “[S]ometimes nothing is actually the optimal thing to do.”

4. Learn More about Investing in Green Companies

It’s not lucrative being green. At least, that is the perception of many investors, who cite lower share prices as a reason to avoid sinking money into environmentally sustainable companies. But are those investors correct in assuming that green firms perform poorly compared to others?

No, argues research from Kellogg finance professor Ravi Jagannathan and his colleagues. In fact, the researchers say, just the opposite is true: companies with sustainable practices can be a better bet.

Why? As the public becomes more concerned about environmental issues, more stringent environmental laws are likely to pass, and consumers will demand industry changes. These shifts will favor companies with higher ESG—environmental, social, and governance—ratings over those that overlook sustainability concerns.

Investors are taking note. A growing number of professional money managers are using companies’ ESG ratings to help identify promising firms to invest in.

Investors may want to focus on environmental metrics, says Jagannathan, because companies that aren’t prepared to weather change will “lose out in the long run.”

5. Understand Your Impact Investing Options

While some investors are choosing socially and environmentally responsible ventures for profit, others are equally interested in impact. As the field of impact investing expands, where can socially-minded investors identify opportunities?

Amit Bouri, CEO of the Global Impact Investing Network, points to tools like ImpactBase, which is a free, searchable online directory of impact-investment funds and products available to accredited investors.

“It started with about 30 impact-investment funds and products, and now has over 400,” says Bouri. “You can use this tool to get a sense of the opportunity that is out there.

“Many of the portfolio consulting firms that serve the large endowments, foundations, and pension plans are building significant databases of impact- and sustainable-investment funds,” adds David Chen, an adjunct professor of finance and program director of impact investing at Kellogg, and chairman of Equilibrium Capital Group.

“The comment ‘I couldn’t find these products’ may have been accurate three years ago—but today there’s no excuse,” says Chen.

Editor’s note: This information does not constitute investment advice, and should be used for informational purposes only.

Featured Faculty

David Chen

Adjunct Professor of Finance

Janice C. Eberly

John L. and Helen D. Russell Professor of Finance and Faculty Director, Kellogg Public-Private Initiative

Ravi Jagannathan

Chicago Mercantile Exchange/John F. Sandner Professor of Finance and Co-Director, Financial Institutions and Markets Research

Robert Korajczyk

Harry G. Guthmann Distinguished Professor of Finance and Co-Director, Financial Institutions and Markets Research Center

Matthew Lyle

Associate Professor of Accounting Information & Management

Louis Simpson

Senior Fellow and Adjunct Professor of Finance

Suggested For You

Most Popular

Organizations

How Are Black–White Biracial People Perceived in Terms of Race?

Understanding the answer—and why black and white Americans’ responses may differ—is increasingly important in a multiracial society.

Careers

Don’t Let Complacency Derail Your Career

How to hone your learning agility and take good risks.

Leadership

Take 5: Fine-Tuning Your Powers of Persuasion

From understanding power dynamics to telling a memorable story, here’s how to sell your ideas.

Most Popular Podcasts

Careers

Podcast: Our Most Popular Advice on Improving Relationships with Colleagues

Coworkers can make us crazy. Here’s how to handle tough situations.

Social Impact

Podcast: How You and Your Company Can Lend Expertise to a Nonprofit in Need

Plus: Four questions to consider before becoming a social-impact entrepreneur.

Careers

Podcast: Attract Rockstar Employees—or Develop Your Own

Finding and nurturing high performers isn’t easy, but it pays off.

Marketing

Podcast: How Music Can Change Our Mood

A Broadway songwriter and a marketing professor discuss the connection between our favorite tunes and how they make us feel.

More in Finance & Accounting