Why Healthcare Spending Has Slowed
Skip to content
Healthcare Economics Policy Feb 1, 2016

Why Healthcare Spending Has Slowed

Is the Affordable Care Act getting too much credit?

Healthcare professionals try to diagnose why healthcare spending has slowed.

Runeer via iStock

Spending on healthcare in the U.S. has slowed dramatically in the last eight years. President Obama credits the Affordable Care Act (ACA). But Kellogg School strategy professors wondered if there was a different mechanism at work.

Did spending slow as the overall economy stalled during the recession? And will it rebound as the economy improves?

The answers to these questions are critical. Healthcare spending represented over 17 percent of U.S. GDP in 2011—and where it is headed in the future impacts a lot of players.

“If the ACA has had a profound, permanent effect on health spending,” says David Dranove, a professor of strategy, “that would lead everyone to reduce spending forecasts, and that would affect government budgets, business spending, and other areas.”

If Obama is right and the ACA has driven a structural shift in healthcare spending, that would free up federal resources for other aspects of the economy, from defense to education. If, on the other hand, the reduced spending was simply due to the slowdown, healthcare spending would inevitably rise with the economy.

“There’s only so much healthcare that Mark Zuckerberg is going to purchase.”

To get at the answer, Dranove worked with Craig Garthwaite, an assistant professor of strategy, and Christopher Ody, a research assistant professor of strategy, to link variations in local employment rates to healthcare spending. The researchers found that economic factors explain a full 70 percent of the reduction in private healthcare spending and a smaller but still meaningful proportion of reduced post-recession Medicare spending.

That means the ACA has not had the more permanent, structural effect on spending that the Obama administration has touted and that a rising economy most likely heralds an upswing in healthcare spending.

Looking Local

The researchers sought to understand why healthcare spending grew only 3.3 percent a year from 2008 to 2011 after having grown 6.6 percent annually from 2000 to 2007.Previous studies have linked macroeconomic trends to healthcare spending. But those studies are not recent, and most used the GDP as the economic measure. Dranove says this is a poor barometer of economic health since the downturn.

“The GDP recovered quickly, but the growth is in the tail—and there’s only so much healthcare that Mark Zuckerberg is going to purchase,” he says. In other words, average Americans, whose spending drives the health economy, have not seen as fast a recovery as those at the top of the income ladder. So the researchers needed a more relevant economic measure.

They found it in local employment data.

“The economy has recovered unevenly, with some regions recovering quickly or never really hit hard, and others still recovering to this day,” Dranove says. By using local employment rates, the researchers were able to study the link between the health of a local economy and spending on healthcare there.

“Especially for people under 65, even if you have health insurance, not everything is covered,” Dranove says. “You might have a big deductible and coinsurance, so even if the doctor says you should have this done, you might not automatically agree. Cost is an issue.”

To understand healthcare spending, the researchers used data from the Health Care Cost Institute (HCCI), a nonprofit organization that built the largest database to date on U.S. private healthcare insurance claims.

They examined HCCI data on spending from 40 million people enrolled with Aetna, United Healthcare, and Humana—three of the largest private U.S. insurers. They studied any spending that went toward the services of healthcare providers, as well as spending on medical supplies, drugs, devices, and diagnostics.

Their findings were clear and dramatic: better local economic conditions, as measured by employment rates, meant higher local healthcare spending, and vice versa. For example, harder-hit areas like Las Vegas showed much smaller increases in healthcare spending than did locales less affected by the recession, such as Dallas.

Overall, economic conditions accounted for 70 percent of the observed reduction in healthcare spending in 2009–2011 compared with the 2007–2009 period. “The ACA might explain the other 30 percent of the spending reduction,” Dranove says, “but it would be a gross overstatement to say that the legislation was responsible for the majority of the reduction in overall health spending.”

What About Medicare?

The findings received significant coverage in the press when published in August 2014. But some who read it argued that the results did not apply to Medicare beneficiaries because they tended not to be employed and thus their healthcare spending would be less affected by the labor market.

“We agreed it wouldn’t have as big a direct effect on seniors,” Dranove says, “but some seniors work and some rely on family to help pay for medical bills, so there still might be some effect of economic conditions on health spending.”

Inspired by these comments, the researchers performed a second study. This time they linked local employment rates to data on Medicare spending from the government’s Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services. Their findings, while still meaningful, were less dramatic.

The researchers found that economic factors explained about 14 percent of reduced healthcare spending among Medicare beneficiaries during 2009–2012 compared with 2004–2009. Other contributors included the ACA’s built-in payment reductions for services covered by Medicare. (Medicare spending represents about 20 percent of recent national healthcare spending.)

Overall then, while economic factors again played a role in healthcare spending, it was much smaller than for private spending. “People under 65 [those not on Medicare] simply have more skin in the game,” in the form of a greater dependence on employment-related income, Dranove says. “So it’s a more direct affect.”

An Uncertain Future

Recent healthcare spending trends have provided strong support for the researchers’ findings. As the economy has recovered, spending has increased to close to pre-2008 levels. “Health spending has picked up,” Dranove says, “exactly what we would have predicted from our model.”

Still, one of the biggest takeaways from the research is not to jump to conclusions about the ACA’s effects on healthcare spending so far—in either direction. “If we see a slowdown in health spending for the private sector now,” Dranove says, “that would mean the ACA is actually overcoming economic effects on spending—and that would mean a huge structural change.”

Featured Faculty

Walter J. McNerney Professor of Health Industry Management; Faculty Director of PhD Program; Professor of Strategy

Professor of Strategy; Herman Smith Research Professor in Hospital and Health Services Management; Director of Healthcare at Kellogg

Member of the Strategy Department from 2013 to 2021

About the Writer
Sachin Waikar is a freelance writer based in Evanston, Illinois.
About the Research

Dranove, David, Craig Garthwaite, and Christopher Ody. 2014. “Health Spending Slowdown Is Mostly Due to Economic Factors, Not Structural Change in the Healthcare Sector.” Health Affairs (33 No. 8): 1399–1406.

Dranove, David , Craig Garthwaite, and Christopher Ody. 2015. “The Economic Downturn and Its Lingering Effects Reduced Medicare Spending Growth by $4 Billion in 2009-12.” Health Affairs (34 No. 8): 1368–1375.

Read the original

Most Popular This Week
  1. One Key to a Happy Marriage? A Joint Bank Account.
    Merging finances helps newlyweds align their financial goals and avoid scorekeeping.
    married couple standing at bank teller's window
  2. Take 5: Yikes! When Unintended Consequences Strike
    Good intentions don’t always mean good results. Here’s why humility, and a lot of monitoring, are so important when making big changes.
    People pass an e-cigarette billboard
  3. How Are Black–White Biracial People Perceived in Terms of Race?
    Understanding the answer—and why black and white Americans may percieve biracial people differently—is increasingly important in a multiracial society.
    How are biracial people perceived in terms of race
  4. Will AI Eventually Replace Doctors?
    Maybe not entirely. But the doctor–patient relationship is likely to change dramatically.
    doctors offices in small nodules
  5. Entrepreneurship Through Acquisition Is Still Entrepreneurship
    ETA is one of the fastest-growing paths to entrepreneurship. Here's how to think about it.
    An entrepreneur strides toward a business for sale.
  6. Take 5: Research-Backed Tips for Scheduling Your Day
    Kellogg faculty offer ideas for working smarter and not harder.
    A to-do list with easy and hard tasks
  7. How to Manage a Disengaged Employee—and Get Them Excited about Work Again
    Don’t give up on checked-out team members. Try these strategies instead.
    CEO cheering on team with pom-poms
  8. Which Form of Government Is Best?
    Democracies may not outlast dictatorships, but they adapt better.
    Is democracy the best form of government?
  9. What Went Wrong at AIG?
    Unpacking the insurance giant's collapse during the 2008 financial crisis.
    What went wrong during the AIG financial crisis?
  10. The Appeal of Handmade in an Era of Automation
    This excerpt from the book “The Power of Human" explains why we continue to equate human effort with value.
    person, robot, and elephant make still life drawing.
  11. 2 Factors Will Determine How Much AI Transforms Our Economy
    They’ll also dictate how workers stand to fare.
    robot waiter serves couple in restaurant
  12. When Do Open Borders Make Economic Sense?
    A new study provides a window into the logic behind various immigration policies.
    How immigration affects the economy depends on taxation and worker skills.
  13. Why Do Some People Succeed after Failing, While Others Continue to Flounder?
    A new study dispels some of the mystery behind success after failure.
    Scientists build a staircase from paper
  14. Sitting Near a High-Performer Can Make You Better at Your Job
    “Spillover” from certain coworkers can boost our productivity—or jeopardize our employment.
    The spillover effect in offices impacts workers in close physical proximity.
  15. How the Wormhole Decade (2000–2010) Changed the World
    Five implications no one can afford to ignore.
    The rise of the internet resulted in a global culture shift that changed the world.
  16. What’s at Stake in the Debt-Ceiling Standoff?
    Defaulting would be an unmitigated disaster, quickly felt by ordinary Americans.
    two groups of politicians negotiate while dangling upside down from the ceiling of a room
  17. What Happens to Worker Productivity after a Minimum Wage Increase?
    A pay raise boosts productivity for some—but the impact on the bottom line is more complicated.
    employees unload pallets from a truck using hand carts
  18. Immigrants to the U.S. Create More Jobs than They Take
    A new study finds that immigrants are far more likely to found companies—both large and small—than native-born Americans.
    Immigrant CEO welcomes new hires
  19. How Has Marketing Changed over the Past Half-Century?
    Phil Kotler’s groundbreaking textbook came out 55 years ago. Sixteen editions later, he and coauthor Alexander Chernev discuss how big data, social media, and purpose-driven branding are moving the field forward.
    people in 1967 and 2022 react to advertising
  20. 3 Traits of Successful Market-Creating Entrepreneurs
    Creating a market isn’t for the faint of heart. But a dose of humility can go a long way.
    man standing on hilltop overlooking city
More in Healthcare