Consumers Lose Out When Health Insurers Offer Lots of Plans
Skip to content
Healthcare Feb 2, 2023

Consumers Lose Out When Health Insurers Offer Lots of Plans

While extra choices are usually considered a good thing, insurers are able to use them strategically to maximize profits.

Person reading giant book titled "Open Enrollment Choices"

Yevgenia Nayberg

Based on the research of

Hector Chade

Victoria Marone

Amanda Starc

Jeroen Swinkels

When people have to choose a new health-insurance plan, they’re usually presented with several options. And while, generally, consumers appreciate choice, Amanda Starc, an associate professor of strategy at the Kellogg School, wondered if there’s a downside to all this choice when it comes to health insurance.

“In lots of markets we think choice is a good thing,” Starc says. “People have different preferences, and they might want different things. If I give you three choices instead of two, then worst-case scenario, if the third choice doesn’t work for you, just don’t take it, right?”

But the health-insurance market may not follow this rule of thumb, because in this sector, unlike, say, groceries or electronics, “the cost depends on who is buying the product,” Starc says. While insurers can no longer refuse to serve people with existing medical conditions or charge them higher premiums, factors like age and place of residence can influence the price consumers pay.

Starc and some colleagues wondered, given the nature of the health-insurance market, what set of plans insurers would offer. Can they increase profits by offering both generous and high-deductible plans? And, if so, what happens to the consumer? But it was difficult to answer these questions because nobody had previously studied the relationship between insurance plan design, insurer pricing, and the impact on consumers.

So Starc did just that in recent research with Kellogg professor of strategy Jeroen Swinkels, along with collaborators Hector Chade, at Arizona State, and Victoria Marone, at UT Austin. They created a model that showed that insurers with the ability to strategically set prices will offer more insurance-plan choices to consumers to increase their bottom lines, at consumers’ expense.

“Our work shows that insurers may act strategically to extract more money from consumers using the mechanism of choice,” Starc says.

A model of choice

The researchers built a model for what might happen if a monopolist insurer (the only one in a given market) had pricing power and could decide how many and what kind of plans to offer consumers. Their model quickly revealed a key driving force: insurers with the ability to price products strategically have incentive to offer consumers a variety of plans to learn more about them.

Why is that the case?

By offering more plan options, insurers can use what they learn about consumers to better optimize prices.

By offering more plan options, insurers can use what they learn about consumers to better optimize prices. For example, say you are offered a gold, silver, and bronze plan and you choose gold. Now the insurance company knows something about you. “You might be really sick. You might be really worried about the small chance of big medical expenses. Or you might know that, once you have generous insurance and no out-of-pocket costs, you’re going to consume a bunch more care,” Starc says. “The insurance company wants to use this information to maximize profits.” This means that, sometimes, restricting what the insurance company can do can help consumers.

Impact on consumers

One negative implication of insurers having complete control over plans and pricing is that it might lead to more people going without insurance.

“In a world where the government offers a basic minimal level of insurance as a default, our model shows that a monopolist insurer may ultimately not sell plans to about 40 percent of consumers,” Starc says. “That’s not because they would deny insurance to sick people [as was the case with preexisting conditions in the past], but because they would set prices so high that a large chunk of people simply wouldn’t buy it.” And because the insurer is able to earn higher profits off the consumers who do buy plans, it would end up ahead even with the loss of other customers.

Unfortunately, the findings here apply well beyond monopoly situations. “The basic mechanism we saw likely extends to any setting where the insurer has some ability to set pricing,” Starc says. “That includes an ACA-type setting, where there may be a few insurers competing.”

Calling on the government

So what can be done to protect consumers from this seeming tyranny of insurance choice?

“For one,” Starc says, “we can try to ensure that the insurance market is more competitive. There have been lots of antitrust cases about the market power insurers might have, motivated by a need to limit that power.”

Government intervention is another option, Starc says. “The government intervenes with insurance partly to ensure sicker people have choices beyond very expensive options,” she says. “But we show another reason they should get involved: insurers’ ability to set prices higher than costs in a way that could lead to underinsurance.“

Policymakers would need to be “pretty creative” and carefully construct regulations, “keeping in mind the strategic incentives insurers have. It could take the form of taxes, subsidies, mandates, and other measures,” she says.

Ultimately the research highlights a critical area of healthcare requiring ongoing oversight and intervention, for public benefit. “Unfortunately,” Starc says, “what maximizes insurer profits can harm consumers.”

Featured Faculty

Associate Professor of Strategy

Richard M. Paget Professor of Management Policy; Professor of Strategy

About the Writer

Sachin Waikar is a freelance writer based in Evanston, Illinois.

About the Research

Chade, Hector, Victoria Marone, Amanda Starc, and Jeroen Swinkels. 2022. “Multidimensional Screening and Menu Design in Health Insurance Markets.” Working paper.

Read the original

Most Popular This Week
  1. 3 Things to Keep in Mind When Delivering Negative Feedback
    First, understand the purpose of the conversation, which is trickier than it sounds.
  2. Podcast: Workers Are Stressed Out. Here’s How Leaders Can Help.
    On this episode of The Insightful Leader: You can’t always control what happens at work. But reframing setbacks, and instituting some serious calendar discipline, can go a long way toward reducing stress.
  3. What Went Wrong at Silicon Valley Bank?
    And how can it be avoided next time? A new analysis sheds light on vulnerabilities within the U.S. banking industry.
    People visit a bank
  4. How Are Black–White Biracial People Perceived in Terms of Race?
    Understanding the answer—and why black and white Americans may percieve biracial people differently—is increasingly important in a multiracial society.
    How are biracial people perceived in terms of race
  5. Will AI Eventually Replace Doctors?
    Maybe not entirely. But the doctor–patient relationship is likely to change dramatically.
    doctors offices in small nodules
  6. Leaders, Don’t Be Afraid to Admit Your Flaws
    We prefer to work for people who can make themselves vulnerable, a new study finds. But there are limits.
    person removes mask to show less happy face
  7. Which Form of Government Is Best?
    Democracies may not outlast dictatorships, but they adapt better.
    Is democracy the best form of government?
  8. What Went Wrong at AIG?
    Unpacking the insurance giant's collapse during the 2008 financial crisis.
    What went wrong during the AIG financial crisis?
  9. What Happens to Worker Productivity after a Minimum Wage Increase?
    A pay raise boosts productivity for some—but the impact on the bottom line is more complicated.
    employees unload pallets from a truck using hand carts
  10. At Their Best, Self-Learning Algorithms Can Be a “Win-Win-Win”
    Lyft is using ”reinforcement learning” to match customers to drivers—leading to higher profits for the company, more work for drivers, and happier customers.
    person waiting for rideshare on roads paved with computing code
  11. When You’re Hot, You’re Hot: Career Successes Come in Clusters
    Bursts of brilliance happen for almost everyone. Explore the “hot streaks” of thousands of directors, artists and scientists in our graphic.
    An artist has a hot streak in her career.
  12. Why Do Some People Succeed after Failing, While Others Continue to Flounder?
    A new study dispels some of the mystery behind success after failure.
    Scientists build a staircase from paper
  13. Immigrants to the U.S. Create More Jobs than They Take
    A new study finds that immigrants are far more likely to found companies—both large and small—than native-born Americans.
    Immigrant CEO welcomes new hires
  14. Take 5: Tips for Widening—and Improving—Your Candidate Pool
    Common biases can cause companies to overlook a wealth of top talent.
  15. Why Well-Meaning NGOs Sometimes Do More Harm than Good
    Studies of aid groups in Ghana and Uganda show why it’s so important to coordinate with local governments and institutions.
    To succeed, foreign aid and health programs need buy-in and coordination with local partners.
  16. How Has Marketing Changed over the Past Half-Century?
    Phil Kotler’s groundbreaking textbook came out 55 years ago. Sixteen editions later, he and coauthor Alexander Chernev discuss how big data, social media, and purpose-driven branding are moving the field forward.
    people in 1967 and 2022 react to advertising
  17. How Peer Pressure Can Lead Teens to Underachieve—Even in Schools Where It’s “Cool to Be Smart”
    New research offers lessons for administrators hoping to improve student performance.
    Eager student raises hand while other student hesitates.
  18. How Much Do Campaign Ads Matter?
    Tone is key, according to new research, which found that a change in TV ad strategy could have altered the results of the 2000 presidential election.
    Political advertisements on television next to polling place
  19. Take 5: How Fear Influences Our Decisions
    Our anxieties about the future can have surprising implications for our health, our family lives, and our careers.
    A CEO's risk aversion encourages underperformance.
More in Healthcare